Legacy Stuff: Mega-Kudos to DiFi for Torture Report


Dianne-FeinsteinDianne Feinstein’s release of the Senate Intelligence Committee’s report on the CIA’s use of torture is a stand-up, gutsy move likely to endure as the most important act of her long career in Congress.

As a political matter, the easy part for Feinstein was to defy a torrent of inflammatory attacks and threats from conservatives accusing her of treason and worse; as a personal matter, the harder part was to stand up to howls of protest from the national security establishment and other Beltway elites, two groups of whom she long has counted herself a member.

And, oh yeah, she did the right thing for the country, too.

“Releasing this report is an important step to restoring our values and showing the world that we are a just society,” Feinstein said on the Senate floor, calling the CIA’s post 9/11 interrogation program, “a stain on our values and our history.”

Under enormous pressure, Feinstein could have punted, mumbled about bipartisanship and played it safe by letting Republicans water down the report or bury it for good after she loses her committee chairmanship when the new Senate convenes. Such an option was most likely a non-starter for someone of her self-regard, but that she ultimately did not choose it may well stand as the greatest legacy of the 81-year old Senator’s years in Washington.

Four takeaways about Difi and the report:

CIA Torture ReportMiddle of the road: yellow stripes and dead armadillos: Feinstein’s entire career has been an earnest search for the elusive political middle. This time, she found there isn’t one.

Having carried the water of the spook establishment elite for years, Feinstein in the end was left hanging out politically, supported only by predictable congressional liberals, Republican John McCain (the only member of Congress to actually endure torture) and kinda-sorta by the cowardly, feckless White House,

Throughout the compilation of the report, the ever-cautious Ms. Feinstein was torn between her allegiance to and admiration for those who do the nation’s difficult intelligence business and the belief by her and other Democrats on the panel that there must be a public accounting of the C.I.A. conduct to prevent future occurrences.

As recently as Friday, Ms. Feinstein appeared to be having new reservations about releasing the report after being warned by Secretary of State John Kerry, her former Senate colleague, of possible violence overseas and risks to American hostages.

An A+ paper: From start to finish, and throughout the tedious process to produce and surface it, the report has Feinstein’s hardest working-Convent girl-in-the-class imprint all over it.

Five years. Six million documents, 6,000 pages. A 500-page summary, ferhevvinsake. Not to mention reams of grisly and graphic detail, not surprising from a politician (and the daughter of a surgeon) who’s never left the gruesome to the imagination, from her countless mentions of feeling the bullet holes in Harvey Milk’s wrists to the “brain matter spattered on the canned goods,” a phrase she used for years in describing a long-ago grocery store robbery she said helped make her pro-death penalty.

Spy_vs_Spy_Bust_by_DaveIgoFor Feinstein, the specter of losing control of such a singular project, by caving in to pressure not to release the report before she loses control of the Intelligence Committee, surely pushed all her control freak buttons.

How dare you?! No one will ever know for sure, of course, but Feinstein may not have pushed quite so hard for the release of the report if the CIA’s spooks hadn’t decided to spy on her and her staff members.

Beyond her stated claims, speculation has swirled over why Feinstein so surprisingly — and so publicly –— assailed the leading U.S. spy agency, after serving as benefactor for so long…

Some veteran DiFi watchers (we name no names) believe she may have reacted with such outrage for the simple reason that the CIA’s alleged computer incursion touched her personally.

“It’s all about Dianne,” went a familiar refrain during her City Hall years, often accompanied by the rolling of eyes.

69feinWhat goes around comes around: Several years before she won elected office in 1969, Feinstein first came to public attention in San Francisco by conducting her own private investigation of conditions in the women’s county jail.

Then a young and bright Pat Brown appointee to California’s women’s parole board, Feinstein wrote up her findings about inhumane conditions in the local lock-up in a series of articles that the old Hearst Examiner splashed across its front page for several days.

It’s a bit of history worth recalling, at least for those who like their political narratives neat and tidy, as she caps her career half a century later by exposing far more barbarous conditions in a far more evil system of government jails that, thanks to her best efforts, are secret no longer.

subscribe to comments RSS

There are 4 comments for this post

  1. avatar tonyseton says:

    One might say that she redeemed herself after her lengthy service, some of it being quite deplorable. For instance, she (and Schumer) pushed the disgraceful Mukasey nomination through the Senate. And yes, she protected the CIA and other “intelligence” agencies for decades. But she did right this time. Thank goodness.

  2. avatar Opatrny says:

    Not always a DiFi admirer. But this time she done good.

  3. avatar sqrjn says:

    Understanding A) That I haven’t read the report and B) That it apparently outlines efforts at deceiving congress, isn’t the biggest section of the Venn diagram still all the stuff Feinstein knew about all along and now exposes with feigned horror. I might be willing to go along with a little cheering, if not outright forgiveness, for DiFi if she had handed in her resignation along with the majority’s report.

  4. avatar JohnF says:

    Yes, kudos to DiFi for releasing this report. A big thumbs down to those who said the world would come to an end if it was released. Well it has been released and the only thing coming to end is Dick Chaney’s creditability (not that he had any). BTW John Brennan (head of the CIA) gave a press conference/rebuttal earlier today. DiFi (or somebody in her office) live tweeted rebuttals to any deviations from the report with references to the pages where the correct information was contained. That really helps many of the media personnel (Wolf Biltzer) who could not do something like that on the fly. So yes lets hope that this what she is remember for, it will be a good legacy.

Please, feel free to post your own comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.